Research by The Trade Desk, PA Consulting and Brainsights finds balanced media plans outperform social-heavy approaches in persuasion, attention and brand recall.
New research by The Trade Desk, PA Consulting and Brainsights suggests that marketers relying heavily on social media advertising may be missing opportunities for stronger long-term brand growth.
The neuroscience-based study found that balanced media strategies delivered a 47% uplift in persuasion compared with single-channel approaches, while outperforming social-heavy strategies by 1.6 times.
The findings highlight a growing gap between how marketers measure advertising performance and what actually drives long-term business growth, with short-term efficiency metrics often taking priority over broader measures of brand effectiveness.
A survey of 400 marketers conducted as part of the research found that 74% believe the most effective campaigns combine social media with other channels. However, 75% said they favour social platforms because they are familiar, while 72% believe channels that are easier to measure receive disproportionate credit for business success.
The research also found that balanced media plans generated 1.4 times greater attention, 2.3 times stronger brand connection and 1.5 times stronger memory encoding than social-heavy approaches.
Despite recognising the benefits of a broader media mix, one in four marketers admitted to over-investing in paid social advertising.
The findings suggest that while social media remains an important component of modern marketing, relying too heavily on it could limit a brand’s ability to build lasting consumer relationships and recall.
Phil Duffield, vice-president of Northern Europe at The Trade Desk, said social media continued to play an important role in marketing but should not operate in isolation.
He said brands could achieve stronger results by adopting a broader media strategy that reflects how consumers interact with streaming television, audio, gaming and the wider open internet.
The study calls on marketers to look beyond immediate return-on-investment measures and assess how advertising investments contribute to long-term brand effectiveness and business growth.



