In 2025, Meta stood in a US courtroom and proved that its own apps are no longer social.
It was fighting an antitrust case brought by the FTC, and its defence was that it competes with TikTok and YouTube, so it cannot hold a monopoly on “personal social networking”.
In January 2025, people spent 17% of their time on Facebook looking at content from friends. On Instagram it was 7%. Two years earlier, those numbers were 22% and 11%. In November 2025, the judge agreed with Meta and dismissed the case.
The company that invented the friend feed told a judge that friends are now a side feature. Yet most of us in marketing still plan “social” as if people scroll through their cousins’ holiday photos.
People stopped talking
Social media was meant to give people a voice, and fewer of them use it. Ofcom, the UK regulator, found that only 49% of adult social media users in the UK now post, share or comment. In 2024 it was 61%. More people also told Ofcom they worry that something they post today could cause them problems later.
That is UK data. Still, count the friends in your own feed who post every weekend. Most of them are still there, watching.
The feed became a TV channel
Meta moved away from friends because it was chasing TikTok. Scott Galloway’s explanation of TikTok’s rise is the simplest I have read: the app takes away the work of choosing. You open it and the videos start, picked for you, and you never have to post.
Meta saw the same thing in its own numbers. Switching on Reels lifted time spent on Instagram by 48%. Showing Facebook users 20% more posts from friends changed almost nothing.
The same shift reached the living room. By 2024, US adults spent nearly as much time on TikTok as on Netflix, according to eMarketer, and in July 2026 Netflix signed deals for short-form video to keep up. Nielsen’s numbers for that month gave YouTube 14.2% of all US TV viewing, almost double Netflix’s 7.8%.
Streaming and social media now compete for the same hours of the same people. What is winning is something I would call social entertainment.
Social did not die. It moved indoors.
Eugene Healey, who calls this moment the great social media reset, points out that engagement is down but people still hang out online. They just do it in private messages, where brands cannot see them.
I attended a presentation by Grace Kao, Chief Marketing Officer of Snap Inc., on what she called the age of realness. One line stayed with me: in a world where everything can be generated, realness becomes a premium. She also said that private social is how Gen Z connects.
As AI fills the public feed with content nobody really made, the blurry photo a friend sent you an hour ago becomes the most valuable thing on your phone.
Three generations, three internets
Millennials grew up posting in public. Gen Z watched that go wrong. They keep the public account clean and quiet, and they live in group chats and Snaps that disappear.
Gen Alpha never knew a feed made of friends. Their first screens were YouTube and game worlds, and for them being social online means playing together or sending a voice note. The public feed is simply what they watch.
Saudi Arabia is the clearest example I know. Snapchat reaches more than 90% of 13 to 34 year olds in the Kingdom, and they open it more than 50 times a day. Our young people moved to private social years before the rest of the world started writing reports about it.
So what are we actually doing about it?
Very little, and I include myself. Most brands still brief “social” the way we did in 2015. Agencies sell a monthly calendar of 30 posts that the algorithm shows to almost nobody. We report engagement rates while half the audience has stopped commenting.
Now don’t get me wrong. The public feed still delivers reach, and I am not telling anyone to leave it.
The first fix is to treat the public feed as what it has become, an entertainment channel. Would someone choose our content over the next TikTok, or the next episode on Netflix? If the honest answer is no, it is media spend dressed up as content, and we should plan and buy it as media.
The second fix is harder. The real conversation now happens where we are not invited, and no budget buys a seat in a family group chat. What we can do is make something people want to send into one. A share into a private chat tells me more than any number of likes ever did.
The platforms already admitted it in court. The only ones still pretending social media is social are the people paying for it.
(Nabil Sleiman is VP of Marketing Services at Almarai. A Marketer’s Unpopular Opinion is a series where he questions the beliefs the industry holds without thinking, and backs every challenge with data)



